Give us a call - Newark: 740-345-2000 | Mt. Vernon: 740-392-9888

Per the Executive Orders issued by the DeWine Administration as a result of the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic.

Insurance agencies are permitted to continue business, but must comply with the social distancing and sanitization protocols as well as special hours set for vulnerable populations.


Effective March 24 

We will be Open for Only, Age 60+ and Vulnerable Clients from 9-10 am.  We will be Open 10-5 pm. for the remainder of our clients.  For the safety of you and our staff , please strictly limit your office visits.  We are always be available by phone and email.


Be Safe and Please let us know how we can help.


Our Thoughts and Prayers are with all of you,


JP, Terry, Brian, Tim, Leda, Donna, Mike, Shannon, Cathy, Kim, Terie, Zach, Natolie and Sara 

Madison Collins Stephens Agency

 Over 200 years of combined experience.

James L. Madison founded the original agency in 1955 and was located in the old Newark Trust building.  It was later changed to Madison-Collins Insurance when Bill Collins became a partner.  At that time the agency was located on Hudson Avenue.

In 1980 John P. Stephens became a partner and the agency’s name became Madison-Collins-Stephens Agency, Inc.

Downtown Newark Location

Mt. Vernon Location
In 1999 Terry Miller, Brian Newkirk & J.P. Stephens Jr. purchased Madison-Collins-Stephens.

With a staff of 12 experienced agents we are now the largest privately owned independent Insurance agency In Licking and Knox County, with access to dozens of individual insurance companies, giving us the ability to competitively insure almost any type of risk.

Call Us Today!

Newark: 740-345-2000 | Mt. Vernon: 740-392-9888